PubCrawler is a leading travel focused search engine. We feature breweries, brewpubs and beer bars as well as most restaurants. Numerous lodging options - hotels and bed and breakfasts are available for booking reservations. We also list nearby attractions such as historic landmarks.

Colter Bay - Buffalo, NY
Reviews -

December 18, 2014 @ 10:14 PM EDT
Member Login | Join | Contact Us
Blog | News | Events rss | Links | Videos | Store Android App now AVAILABLE on your Android!
In the Android Market or at SlideME.
** News ** September 21, 2010 - Now AVAILABLE, Android App. See and buy the app >here or here.
NAVIGATION: Home > Beer Place Search > NY > Buffalo > Colter Bay
No logo - please upload one (logo placeholder)
Type: Beer Bar
Colter Bay
Overall: Great    Score: 72.2 / 100
561 Delaware Avenue
Buffalo, NY 14202
United States
(716) 882-1330
Listed Since: May 1998
Upload Another Menu

also see:
nearby alternative beer places

nearby bed & breakfasts
nearby hotels (w/reservations online)
nearby historic landmarks
nearby restaurants

Beer Guide for Buffalo, NY
Beer Guide for New York

User Actions
Add Review Add Review
Add Review Get Directions
Mail to a Friend Mail a Friend
Join Our Mailing List Join our List
Upload Photo Upload Photo
Update this Place Update this Place
Add Event Add an Event
Do you own or manage this establishment?

No photos available. Photo frame message.
9 Reviews / No photos! Upload one today!
hours of operation

(9 within 5 miles)
1) Pearl Street Grill and Brewery
(0 mile)

2) Prespa
(0 mile)

3) McCarthy's Irish Pub
(1 mile)

4) Ulrich's Tavern
(2 miles)

5) Sterling Place Tavern
(4 miles)

6) Flying Bison Brewing Company
(5 miles)

7) Papa Jake's Saloon
(5 miles)

8) Cole's Restaurant and Bar
(5 miles)

9) Inlet Wines and Inlet Brews
(6 miles)

bed & breakfasts
within 5 miles
1) Arlington Park Inn
2) Beau Fleuve Bed & Breakfast
3) Richmond Place
nearby hotels
w/ online reservations
(historic places)
within 5 miles
1) 33--61 Emerson Place Row
2) Albright-Knox Art Gallery
3) Berkeley Apartments
4) Blessed Trinity Roman Catholic Church Buildings
5) Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society
6) Buffalo City Hall
7) Buffalo Gas Light Company Works
8) Buffalo Main LIght
9) Buffalo North Breakwater South End Light
10) Connecticut Street Armory
11) County and City Hall
12) Dorsheimer, William, House
13) Durham Memorial A.M.E. Zion Church
14) Eberhardt Mansion
15) EDWARD M. COTTER (fireboat)
16) Hellenic Orthodox Church of the Annunciation
17) How, James and Fanny, House
18) Johnston, Edwin M. and Emily S., House
19) Kelly, Col. William, House
20) Kleinhans Music Hall
21) Lafayette High School
22) Laurel and Michigan Avenues Row
23) Macedonia Baptist Church
24) Martin, D. D., House Complex
25) Martin, Darwin D., House
26) NASH (harbor tug)
27) Prudential Building
28) Roosevelt, Theodore, Inaugural National Historic Site
29) Shea's Buffalo Theater
30) South Buffalo North Side Light
31) St. Andrew's Evangelical Lutheran Church Complex
32) St. Paul's Cathedral
33) St. Paul's Episcopal Cathedral
34) Stone Farmhouse
35) Trico Plant No. 1
36) U.S. Post Office
37) USS THE SULLIVANS (destroyer)
38) Wile, M., and Company Factory Building
39) Woodlawn Avenue Row
40) Young Men's Christian Association Central Building

(within 2 miles)
1) 223 Allen St Inc
2) 3 Fat Guys & A Shot Glass
3) 64 Franklin Inc
4) 658 Bar & Lounge
5) 67 West
6) 99 Fast Food Restaurant
7) A & L Ice Creamery Lunchette
8) A Train Inc
9) Acropolis Family Restaurant
10) Albert's Family Restaurant
11) Allen St Hardware Store Cafe
12) Ambrosia Restaurant
13) American Legion
14) Anchor Bar
15) Andre's Pizzeria
16) Anna's Tavern
17) Aqua
18) Aramatic Refreshment Svc
19) Aramis Pizza
20) Arby's
21) Armory Restaurant
22) Arthur's Pub Inc
23) Astoria
24) Au Bon Pain
25) Avenue Pizza & Submarine Take
26) Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant
27) Bada Bing
28) Barrel House
29) Barristers
30) Batter's Box Gift Shop
31) Bellini's
32) Betty's
33) Big Shotz
34) Bijou Grille
35) Birchfield's
36) Birge Mansion
37) Bisonte Trading Co
38) Blue Moon Cafe
39) Break Time Takeout
40) Broderick Park Inn
41) Buddies
42) Buffalo Beef & Wing Co
43) Buffalo Chop House
44) Buffalo Discount
45) Buffalo House
46) Burger King
47) Burger King
48) Cafe 59
49) Cafe Petit
50) Calumet Arts Cafe
51) Campagna Euro Grille
52) Campbell's Pub
53) Captain Of The Sea
54) Carbones Pizza & Subs
55) Caruso's Grill
56) Casa-Di-Pizza
57) Cathode Ray
58) Cecelia's Ristorante
59) Center City Cafe
60) Century Grill
61) Charlie The Butcher's Express
62) China Express
63) Chinese Kitchen
64) Chowbella's Gourmet Deli
65) Chris' NY Sandwich Co
66) Club Marcella
67) Club One
68) Cobalt Nightclub
69) Cobblestone
70) Coda Restaurant
71) Colter Bay Grill
72) Continental
73) Courtyard Cafe
74) Courtyard Restaurant
75) Cozumel Grill
76) Crocodile Bar
77) Custard Corner
78) Dagwood's & More
79) Danny Zack's Bar & Grill
80) Desiderio's Restaurant & Bar
81) Destinis Take Out
82) Ding How Express
83) Dinny's Place
84) Dipirro's Pizzeria
85) Ditondo's Tavern
86) Dollar Express Cafe
87) Donovan's Pub
88) Dough Bois
89) East Ferry & Jefferson Fish
90) Edritos Fresh Mexican Grill
91) Elmwood-Anderson Corp
92) Elsworth Of Buffalo Corp
93) Essex Pub
94) Everything's Special
95) Exquisite Catering
96) Family Food Market
97) Famous Corner Pizzeria
98) Fat Bob's Smokehouse
99) Fat Franks Pizza & Subs
100) Fera's Lunch Hour
101) Fera's Market Arcade
102) Fera's On Franklin
103) Fiddle Heads Restaurant
104) Floyd's Steel Drums Catering
105) Foster's Lounge
106) Founding Fathers Restaurant
107) Friends On Allen
108) Frizzy's Bar & Grill
109) Fugazi
110) Gabriels Gate Restaurant
111) Gallery 101 Bistro
112) Garris Bbq
113) Gigi's Restaurant
114) Gino & Joe's Pizza
115) Glass Abbey
116) Golden Gloves Grill
117) Golden Palm
118) Good Morning Chefs Restaurant
119) Gourmet Store
120) Grant Street Diner
121) Great Circle Restaurant
122) Greyhound Food Svc
123) Grill
124) Groove
125) Guido Fienberg's Sport Deli Br
126) Gusto's Steak House
127) Happy Garden Restaurant
128) Happy Jack's Restaurant & Tavern
129) Hatch Restaurant
130) Hemmingway's Restaurant
131) Hip Hops
132) Hoagie Brothers Giant Subs
133) Hollywood Pastas & Deli
134) House O Quinn
135) House Of China
136) India Garden
137) Innomarque
138) J T Murphy's
139) Jade
140) Java Temple
141) Jenny's Restaurant
142) Jim's Place
143) Jim's Steak-Out
144) Jim's Steak-Out
145) Jimmy Mac's
146) Jonny's C's New Yawk Deli
147) Joseph Howard Jr Restaurant
148) Just Pasta
149) K Gallagher's
150) K Gallagher's
151) Karam's Korner
152) Keystone Grill
153) Kfc
154) Kfc
155) Kim Long Chinese Take Out
156) King's Court Restaurant Inc
157) L & M
158) La Luna
159) La Nova Pizzeria
160) LA Shante's Chicken & Waffles
161) Lafayette Blues Room
162) Laughlins Beef & Barrel Inc
163) Le Metro Bakery & Cafe
164) Lee's Cafe
165) Left Bank
166) Long Fellows Restaurant
167) Lord Chumley's Restaurant
168) Lotis Restaurant & Martini Lng
169) Louie's Foot Long Hot Dogs
170) Louies Foot Long Hot Dog
171) Lupita's Mexican Cafe & Ctrng
172) Lydia's On Pearl
173) Main Menu
174) Main Street Cafe
175) Malamute Tavern
176) Marco's Italian Restaurant
177) Marotto's & Du Bois Inc
178) Marriott Food Svc Management
179) Mc Bride's Irish Pub
180) Mc Carthy's Restaurant
181) Mc Donald's
182) Mc Donald's
183) Mc Donald's
184) Mc Donald's
185) Mc Donald's
186) Mc Monkeez
187) Melanie's Sweets Unlimited
188) Morning Glory Cafe
189) Mother's Restaurant
190) Moura's New York Style Deli
191) Mr Dan's
192) Mulligan's Brick Bar
193) Mykonos Restaurant
194) Nektar
195) Nero's Restaurant
196) New Masten Easton Lounge
197) New York Pizza
198) Niagara Cafe
199) Nietzsche's
200) North Street Sub-Way
201) Oliver's Catering At Kleinhans
202) Opium Lounge
203) Osake
204) Palm Tree Restaurants
205) Panaro's
206) Panda Restaurant
207) Papaya Restaurant
208) Pat Mc Ginty's Restaurant
209) Paulie's Pizza
210) Pearl Street Grill & Brewery
211) Peking Kitchen
212) Perfect Dough Inc
213) Personal Touch Food Svc
214) Pettibones Grille
215) Pizza Hut
216) Pizza Towne
217) Place
218) Platinum Night Club
219) Prespa
220) Prima Pizza Pasta
221) Progress Food Market
222) Q 44 Allen St Bflo Inc
223) Quaker Bonnet Eatery
224) Radisson Suites Downtown
225) Rainbow Deli
226) Rendezvous
227) Reservoir Bar
228) Restaurant
229) Romanello's Restaurants
230) Route 66
231) Rue Franklin Restaurant
232) Ry-Worth Corp
233) Ryan's NY Deli Inc
234) Sacco's Last Call Lounge
235) Saturn
236) Sensation-Z
237) Shanghai Red's
238) Shebeen
239) Shop Smart Food Store
240) Simply Lunch
241) Skyway Tavern
242) Soho Bar
243) Spirits Of Allentown
244) Spot Coffee Kitchen
245) Spot Coffee Roastery
246) Star Of The East
247) Starbucks
248) Statler Ballroom By Samuel's
249) Statler Towers
250) Subway Sandwiches & Salads
251) Subway Sandwiches & Salads
252) Sue's Ny Deli
253) Sugarbowl Take Out
254) Sunny Side Deli
255) Swannie House
256) Sylvias's Place
257) Taki's Restaurant
258) Tasty's Cafe
259) Tgi Friday's
260) Theo's Place
261) Third Room
262) Tijuana Taco Inc
263) Tim's Rendezvous
264) Towne Restaurant
265) Ultimate Restaurants Inc
266) Underground Nightclub
267) Utopia
268) Vargas Take Out
269) Violanti's Restaurant-Pizzeria
270) Wah Sing Restaurant
271) Washington Square Restaurant
272) Washington Street Grill
273) Waterfront Deli
274) Wendy's
275) Wishbone Barbeque Inc
276) Ya Ya Bayou Brewhouse
277) Zestos
278) Zip's Food & Beverage Shoppe
279) Zoobar
nearby stuff

DUI lawyer
DWI lawyer
gift certificates
homes for sale
houses for rent
local bands
web hosting

Overall Average User Rating
Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Great Great Good Good
PubCrawler Tee Shirts
Individual User Reviews
Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
N/A Good N/A Lousy Lousy
Had friends in from out of town that where staying near by (Coulter Bay) so we planed to meet there.. We got there first .. Took 15 min. for the three bartenders to take our order so busy talking to each other.. would like to say we where the only ones waiting but three of us counting two other couples. Found out they have two way of serving people one for strait people an one for gay .. We ordered a vodka cran 10 oz. size glass an a soda.. 7 bucks an change no vodka an the sweetest cran we have ever tasted.. Our friends (a strait couple) came they ordered a beer an a vodka cran . Glass was now a pint size for the beer an the vodka cran. Still no vodka.. Beer glass has something stuck in side glass.. After 20.00 bucks with tip an shitty service we left for anywhere but COLTERBAY.. Never to go again.. Sucks we have been many times for dinner .. Will not pay to be treated like second class ..

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from William Dorzbacher William Dorzbacher, tonawanda , NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
N/A N/A Great Good So So
The food is very good and it's a fun place but...beware! The soda price is NOT on the menu and the soda is NOT free refills. I not-so-expensive lunch turned into $9 on soda-way more than I had wanted to spend.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Heather Heather, Buffalo, NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Great Great Great Great
I had walked past this place many times while in town for the Allentown Art Festival but hadn't stopped in. I did this time based on the reviews here. I was NOT disapointed!! They have 24 taps: of note are Arogant Bastard, Smuttynose Brown, Ellicottville Pale Ale, Brooklyn Brown, Flying Bison, Blue Moon, and Boddingtons. I have never tasted fresher EBC--that includes at the brewery. It was incredible. The food and service were great! This is a must stop. Tuesday import drafts are 2.75 and Saturday local brews (Flying Bison and EBC) are 2.75.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Bill Laubert Bill Laubert, North Hornell, NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Awesome! Awesome! Great Awesome!
They serve Ellicotville Pale Ale for $2.75 on Sat. What's not to love. The selection is superb for a Buffalo Bar. Name a place in Buffalo where one can find Harpoon Winter Warmer and Sam Winter on tap at the same time. Carry the usual standard line and quality beers on tap. Can get blind drunk without visiting the ATM again. Girls will use the boys room if there is a line. Weekdays sometimes empty which enables you to make the bar your private party. Carry Flying Bison. Friend stated that the Chicken Gumbo soup was the best soup he had ever had. Pretty bold statement. Last St Pats ran out of Killians and served Guiness at same price. Bartenders and waitresses skilled. Will give you matches. Quick to refill empty glasses. They don't pick up tips quickly. The Jackalope by the enterance is priceless. All they have to do is stop serving bottles of Blue.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Black and Tans Black and Tans, Sunny Syracuse, NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Great Great Great Great
Colter Bay is your basic good drinking bar with great selection of draft and spirits. Bartender informed us that lot of new hand crafted beers on the way for fall.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Ralo Pockington Ralo Pockington, buffalo, NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Good N/A Good Good
I was initially impressed with Colter Bay. Lots of good-looking taps, nice enough place, not overpoweringly noisy, cute bartenders (I like looking at good-looking women, deal with it). Sounds good, right? Then I looked at what was going on. First, about 1/3 of the taps were swill. Second, about 4/5 of the taps were all from the same distributor, who is obviously having a LOT to say about what goes on tap at Colter Bay. Finally, when I looked down the bar, you know what I saw people drinking? Wine, mixed drinks, and bottles of Blue. In a crowded bar, I saw 5 pints of draft beer, and one of them was mine. Not a great sign. I understand Colter Bay was one of Buffalo's original multitaps: too bad they've wandered.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Lew Bryson Lew Bryson, Newtown, PA

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Great Great Great Great Great
Newly discovered in my business travels. Nice selection of premium microbrews, NOT just the same ole BUD, MILLER, and COORS...

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review Washington, PA

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Good Good So So Good Good
Good beer choice of imports and local microbrews. Normal brewpub atmosphere.

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Mike Kirst Mike Kirst, Dunkirk, NY

Beer Quality Beer Selection Food Service Overall
Good Great Great Good Good

Write Your Review Reply to this Review Report Review See more reviews from Dave Chapus Dave Chapus, Rochester, NY

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Custom Search

(0.789 seconds) 22:14:55,